Most Feedback Isn’t Too Harsh, It’s Too Vague
18 July 2025
We often tiptoe around feedback like a parent around a sleeping baby.
We soften, dilute, or delay it … petrified it might land too hard.
But in practice, most feedback doesn’t hurt because it’s “too honest”.
It hurts because it’s too vague.
“You need to step up.”
“That didn’t really land.”
“You’re not being strategic enough.”
What do those even mean?
If feedback can’t be understood, it can’t be used, and if it can’t be used, it becomes noise - not growth.
Here’s the shift:
Replace judgment with observation
Replace labels with examples
Replace critique with clarity
Try this instead:
“In yesterday’s meeting, we were expecting a clear recommendation. What you shared raised good points, but we left unsure of your conclusion. Next time, can you signal your position more directly?”
Now that’s feedback someone can act on.
The goal isn’t just to say what you think.
It’s to say it in a way that helps someone get better.
Vague is safe.
Clear is kind.
Remember, the path to extraordinary is walked with a thousand small steps, you’re doing great!
Small Steps, Giant Leaps is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Barry Marshall-Graham
Executive coach and leadership advisor
Get the Difficult Conversations Guide
A practical resource for leaders who want to say the thing that needs saying, without burning bridges or avoiding the moment.
Keep reading
13 April 2026
When Everything Finds You
When every question, tension, and half-finished decision climbs to the leader, the issue isn't workload alone. It is the absence of a clear routing system.
6 April 2026
The Soft Ending Trap
Hard conversations rarely fail at the opening. They fail when leaders soften the close, leave the standard vague, and walk away without a real commitment.
30 March 2026
How to Stop Confusing Frantic Activity with Strategic Momentum
Why senior leaders get trapped in 'heroic execution' and how to build a rhythm that prioritises outcome over activity.
23 March 2026
Why ‘Empowerment’ Fails Without the Clarity of Decision Rights
Why telling your team they are ‘empowered’ often leads to paralysis, and how to fix it with clear decision ownership.
16 March 2026
How Your Desire to be Liked is Creating a Low-Fidelity Culture
Why being a ‘nice’ leader is often a form of standard-avoidance, and how to transition to supportive candour.
13 March 2026
The Weight of Unshared Doubt
Why senior leadership feels lonelier as you rise, and why confidence is often just unshared doubt.
9 March 2026
Why Your Best Advice is the Problem
Why the rush to fix others is actually a specific insecurity, and how to stop.
6 March 2026
The Weight in Your Voice
Your words carry more weight than you realise. Calm authority is often a matter of pace, tone, and the courage to name what matters.
2 March 2026
The Quiet Drift You Inherit
Inherited teams rarely collapse in a moment. They drift. Resetting standards isn't about being harsh, it's about clarity, dignity, and trust.
27 February 2026
When Everyone Owns It
Shared ownership sounds healthy, but when everyone owns a decision, nobody owns the decision. Clarity needs a single accountable owner.
